When it comes to lighting a cigar, choosing the right lighter makes a big difference. Some smokers prefer the traditional elegance of a soft flame lighter, while others rely on the power and efficiency of a torch lighter. Each type has its own strengths, and the best choice depends on your smoking habits, environment, and personal preference.
Let’s break down the key differences, pros and cons, and when to use each one.
What Is a Soft Flame Lighter?
A soft flame lighter produces a natural, steady flame similar to a candle. It’s the classic choice for cigar lovers who appreciate a slow, controlled light. Soft flame lighters typically use butane gas and operate with either a flint wheel or a push-button ignition.
Pros of Soft Flame Lighters
✅ Gentle on Cigars – The lower temperature flame prevents scorching the tobacco, preserving the cigar’s natural flavors.
✅ Classic Look – Soft flame lighters have an elegant, vintage appeal, making them great for formal occasions.
✅ Ideal for Indoor Use – Since the flame isn’t forceful, it works well in wind-free environments like cigar lounges or at home.
✅ Longer Fuel Efficiency – Uses butane more slowly than a torch lighter, meaning fewer refills.
Cons of Soft Flame Lighters
❌ Not Wind-Resistant – Even a light breeze can make it difficult to keep the flame steady.
❌ Takes Longer to Light a Cigar – Requires patience as you slowly toast the foot of the cigar.
❌ Less Precise – The soft flame can be harder to control when lighting large or thick cigars.
Best For:
- Indoor cigar lounges
- Aficionados who enjoy a slow, even toast
- Those who appreciate a classic, refined aesthetic
What Is a Torch Lighter?
A torch lighter generates a powerful, concentrated jet flame, fueled by pressurized butane. These lighters are popular among cigar smokers who need a quick and efficient light. Most torch lighters feature single, double, or triple jet flames, providing intense heat and precision.
Pros of Torch Lighters
✅ Windproof and Reliable – Torch lighters work well outdoors, even in strong wind.
✅ Fast and Efficient – The high-powered flame lights cigars quickly, saving time.
✅ Better for Large Cigars – Easily toasts and lights thick cigars with high ring gauges.
✅ Precise Flame Control – Allows you to direct heat exactly where needed.
Cons of Torch Lighters
❌ High Fuel Consumption – Uses butane quickly, requiring frequent refills.
❌ Risk of Overheating – Can burn the cigar’s wrapper or ruin the flavor if held too close.
❌ Not as Elegant – Torch lighters are practical, but they lack the old-school charm of a soft flame lighter.
Best For:
- Outdoor smoking, travel, and events
- Smokers who prefer quick and powerful ignition
- Larger cigars that need even lighting
Soft Flame vs. Torch Lighter: Which One Should You Use?
| Feature | Soft Flame Lighter | Torch Lighter |
|---|---|---|
| Wind Resistance | Low – Best for indoor use | High – Ideal for outdoor use |
| Lighting Speed | Slow and controlled | Fast and efficient |
| Fuel Efficiency | Uses butane slowly | Uses butane quickly |
| Best for Large Cigars | Not ideal | Yes – Heats large cigars evenly |
| Flavor Preservation | Prevents overheating the cigar | Can scorch tobacco if used too close |
| Aesthetic Appeal | Classic and elegant | Modern and practical |
Final Thoughts
There’s no right or wrong choice when it comes to soft flame vs. torch lighters—it all depends on your smoking style.
If you love the classic ritual of lighting a cigar and mostly smoke indoors, a soft flame lighter is a perfect choice. But if you’re often smoking outdoors, lighting thicker cigars, or want a quick, windproof option, a torch lighter is the way to go.
Whichever you choose, always use high-quality butane to keep your lighter in top condition.
Looking for the best cigar lighters? Check out our premium collection of cigar lighters designed for every smoking experience!
